Book
Reviews
Reformed is Not Enough
by Douglas Wilson
(204 pgs)
This book describes the objectivity of the
new covenant (the one under Christ as opposed to Moses). Wilson
takes baptism as the point of public confession of faith and
a public agreement to abide by the new covenant just as marriage
is a public confession of love and a public agreement to abide
by wedding vows. I don't really get why it's called reformed
is not enough or maybe I just don't remember (reformed refers
to a sect of protestant belief defined by the westminster
confessions; basically is calvinist). Quite frankly, I don't
know if I agree with everything that Wilson says but there's
a good chunk of wise words.
excerpts
Chapter 1: Judas Was a Christian?
According to the Bible, a Christian is one
who would be identified as such by a Muslim. Membership in
the Christian faith is objective - it can be photographed
and fingerprinted. (21)
Chapter 2: Calvanistic Bona Fides
God ordains non-coercively. This makes no
sense to some people, but how many basic doctrines do make
sense? We do not understand how God made the solar system
from nothing any more than how He determined my actions today
without annihilating me. But He did. (26)
Chapter 3: Evangelical Bona Fides
Modern evangelicals write books on How to
Be Born Again, which betrays the fact that they are not grasping
the Lord's teaching in the third chapter of John. Does anyone
write books on how to be born the first time? Who would buy
it? (35)
It is worth noting yet again that if a man
could repent and believe with his old heart, he doesn't really
need a new one. (37)
Chapter 4: Reformation Bona Fides
Too many professing Christians think that
salvation by grace is actually salvation by tiny works.
The temptation, - from the very beginning
- has been to see faith as a point in time affair, after which
the work of sanctification takes over. The Galatians stumbled
into thinking this way: "Are ye so foolish? Having begun
in the Spirit, are y now made perfect by the flesh?"
(Galatians 3:3). (42)
Chapter 8: The Visible and Invisible Church
The heavenly Church is invisible to me for
the same reason the church in China is invisible to me - I
am not there to see it. (71) [the church in glory shall be
the same church as today except cleansed. thus being a member
only of the "invisible" church is not possible]
Chapter 9: Notae Ecclesiae
(marks of the true church)
Rather, the center was Christ preached and
Christ given through the sacraments - to be received by faith.
The Reformers said that you recognize a man by looking at
his face, not the ends of his shoelaces, and if you want to
recognize the Church, then you must look straight at her Head,
who is Christ
.The head, Jesus Christ, is recognized
by the believer in His gospel and sacraments. The Gospel is
the center. (81-82)
Chapter 10: Sacerdotalism
Grace is not a fluid that can fill up a reservoir.
Grace is a covenantal relationship between persons. Now the
Scriptures do tell us that grace can be both added and multiplied.
"Grace and peace be multiplied unto you through the knowledge
of God, and of Jesus our Lord" (2 Peter 1:2, 1 Peter
1:2, Romans 1:7). But we have to be careful not to fall prey
to abstract nouns. If I pray that someone's marital happiness
will increase, I am asking that a relationship between persons
will flourish not that something will happen in their marital
"tank", something that can be checked with a dipstick.
(91-92)
Chapter 13: Church Unity
Ephesians 4:2-6
We find three basic points in this text. The
first is that unity of the Spirit is something to be kept.
It is not manufactured by us but preserved by us. The second
thing is the attitude which is willing to obey this command,
and which rejoices in it. This is the attitude of lowliness,
meekness, patience and loving forebearance. It follows that
the attitudes that defy this word from God would be haughtiness,
insolence, impatience and harshness. The third thing is the
nature and basis of the unity that is to be kept. This given
unity (one body) is grounded in the fact that everything about
the Christian faith has Trinitarian unity - one Spirit, one
hope, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, and one God and Father
of all. (117)
Some think that striving for unity means
refusal to fight over anything, which is not at all correct.
We need to have more Church fights over pastors adopting openness
theism and fewer fights over what color to paint the church
nursery. (118)
We have assumed that love is to be defined
by Hallmark cards rather than by the Word of God. (119)
Chapter 14: Blessed Assurance
A Christian assured of his salvation
- has love for the brothers (1 John 3:14).
(127)
- has true humility of mind (Matthew 18:3).
(127)
- has delight in the means of grace (1 Peter
2:2-3). (127)
When someone is genuinely converted, it is
not necessary to chase him down the street in order to get
him to seek our spiritual food. (128)
- understands spiritual things(1 Corinthians
1:18). (128)
- is obedient(1 John 2-3). (128)
- is chastened for disobedience [by God]
(Hebrews 12:5-8). (129)
Chapter 15: Apostasy: A Real Sin
Elect covenant members who are tempted to
look inside themselves for assurance will only find doubts
(and to their surprise later, eternal life). Elect covenant
members who look to Christ on the cross and Christ on the
throne in evangelical faith receive assurance and life (1
John 5:13). (134-135)
Chapter 16: Heretics and the Covenant
Mark this well: adultery is not the same thing
as divorce. It is certainly covenantal unfaithfulness and
is grounds for divorce, but if there is no divorce, then the
marriage remains binding on both parties. An adulterous husband
is a covenant-breaking husband, not an ex-husband. In short,
we must distinguish between covenant-breaking and covenant-separation.
(144)
Chapter 17: Sons of Belial
What do we call these people within the covenant
who do not understand the first thing about it? We have already
considered the heretics, but there are a large number of people
who are not smart enough to be heretics. What do we call them?
(147)
Chapter 18: False Brothers
The believing heart looks at the prohibition
of stealing, for example, and sees Jesus Christ. The unbelieving
heart looks at the gospel of Christ and sees something to
earn. (153)
Stop trying to pick up grace. You have no
hands. Grace picks you up, out of the miry clay, and sets
your feet on the rock. A true heart knows this. (155)
Epilogue
The objectivity of the covenant is a true
deliverance from morbid introspection. Those who want to come
to the covenant without heart searching clearly do not understand
the basics of the gospel. Abraham and Saul were wretched sinners,
as were we all. But those who want to have their connection
with the covenant be the point where they begin their morbid
heart-searchings do not understand the gospel either. One
of the central points of the new covenant is forgiveness of
sin, and it is not too much to ask that forgiveness result
in
forgiveness.
And when we get this lesson down, we become confident in our
forgiveness and start doubting (with little evidence) the
forgiveness of others
.We are to take the baptisms of
others at face value. We also take the teaching of Scripture
at face value, and the behavior and words of these covenant
members at face value. If there is conflict between what baptism
means and what the baptized are openly doing and saying, then
we are at liberty to point to the inconsistency and say that
it constitutes covenantal faithlessness. But we need to be
extremely wary of pronouncing on the secret things (Deut.
29:29). (193)
|